Currency spread: what it is and what it costs a business in Poland

Business accounts14 min read
Two purple pedestals of different heights with a rose-gold coin on each: the gap between buying and selling a currency
Vivid Editorial Team

The Vivid editorial team writes about company formation, finance and self-employment, with practical guides on business accounts, taxes and funding for founders and the self-employed.

A client in Germany pays an invoice of €10,000, and less arrives in your złoty account than the rate in the news would suggest. The usual reason is the currency spread (spread walutowy): the cost of exchanging money that is built into the rate rather than shown as a separate fee. In short, a spread is the gap between the rate at which a provider sells a currency and the rate at which it buys it.

In a business the spread appears with every exchange: when you receive payment in a foreign currency, pay a supplier abroad or use your card abroad. We show how to calculate it in złoty and as a percentage, which rate to compare it with and what to look for when choosing a provider. All rates in the examples are rounded and for illustration only.

Key points:

  • A currency spread is the gap between a provider’s sell rate and buy rate for a currency.
  • As a percentage, this article calculates it as the rate gap divided by the average rate and multiplied by 100.
  • A business pays the spread both ways: when a client pays, the provider buys the currency; when you pay a supplier, it sells it.
  • For card payments in euro and in currencies of EU countries outside the euro area, the conversion cost is shown as a mark-up over the ECB reference rate before you pay.
  • Compare providers by the total cost of exchanging the same amount, not by a “no commission” claim.

What a currency spread is

What is a currency spread? It is the difference between the sell rate and the buy rate of the same currency in the rate table of a bank, an exchange office or another provider. The provider buys euro from you more cheaply and sells it more dearly, and earns on the difference. The spread also covers the risk that the rate moves before the provider closes its currency position.

A spread is not a commission in the strict sense. A commission is a separate fee you can see on a statement, while a spread is built into the rate, so it is easy to miss. The Polish Payment Services Act does not use the word “spread”. It speaks of the exchange rate applied to a transaction and of a reference exchange rate, meaning a rate made available by the provider or taken from a publicly available source.

Buy rate, sell rate and average rate

The buy rate and the sell rate are two sides of the same table. The buy rate is the price at which a provider buys currency from you, and the sell rate is the price at which it sells currency to you. A bank spread is simply the gap between them in the bank’s table. Narodowy Bank Polski (NBP) publishes average exchange rates in table A and buy and sell rates in table C.

The European Central Bank publishes euro foreign exchange reference rates, usually at around 16:00 CET on working days. The ECB stresses that these rates are for information purposes only and not for transactions. So neither the NBP average rate nor the ECB reference rate is a rate you can exchange money at. They are, however, a good benchmark for checking what your provider’s rate costs you.

A provider’s table is usually based on the market rate, also called the interbank rate, to which the provider adds its margin when selling or from which it subtracts it when buying. The rate a bank or an online exchange office applies can therefore change during the day. Before any larger exchange, check the rate your app shows at that moment and compare it with the average rate of the same day.

What the size of the spread depends on

A spread is not fixed. With the same provider it can vary with several factors:

the currency, as the spread for popular pairs such as EUR/PLN is usually narrower than for less traded currencies,
the channel, as a branch, online banking, an app and an online exchange office can use different rate tables,
the amount and plan, as some providers lower the margin for larger amounts or on higher plans,
the moment of the exchange, as the market rate moves during the day and the provider’s table moves with it.

That is why a percentage spread from one table is not enough to judge an offer. What counts is the total cost of the transaction on your terms: your currency, your amount and your channel.

How to calculate a currency spread

How do you calculate a spread? In złoty it is the sell rate minus the buy rate. As a percentage, divide the difference by the average rate and multiply by 100. If the buy and sell rates sit symmetrically around the average rate, a single exchange, meaning only buying or only selling, costs you roughly half the spread.

Mind the base. Some guides divide the rate gap by the buy rate rather than the average rate, which makes the same spread come out slightly higher. Both methods are correct as long as you use the same one for every offer you compare. In this article we always calculate the percentage spread from the average rate.

An example with rounded rates: the average EUR/PLN rate is PLN 4.4200, the provider buys euro at PLN 4.3600 and sells at PLN 4.4800. The spread is 4.4800 − 4.3600 = PLN 0.1200, or 0.12 / 4.42 × 100 = 2.71%. A single exchange costs PLN 0.06 per euro, about 1.36% of the amount. On invoices it looks like this:

Operation (example rates)RateAmount in PLNDifference from the average rate
Client pays €10,000, provider buys euro4.3600PLN 43,600PLN 600 less
You pay a supplier €5,000, provider sells euro4.4800PLN 22,400PLN 300 more
The same amounts at the average rate of 4.42004.4200PLN 44,200 and PLN 22,100PLN 0

In both cases the cost is about 1.36% of the exchanged amount, even though the statement shows no fee. With a few such invoices a month, the spread becomes a noticeable line in the company’s costs.

A white calculator with purple keys and a plain rose-gold coin: calculating a currency spread

What the spread costs a business

Currency conversion costs depend on which way the money flows and through which channel. In a business you will most often meet three situations.

A client pays in euro

When a client pays in euro and the money lands in a złoty account, the provider buys the euro from you at its buy rate. If you receive euro into a euro account, nothing is exchanged when the money arrives, so you pay the spread only when you decide to convert. When such an account pays off is covered in our article on the euro business account.

You pay a supplier abroad

When you transfer euro to a supplier from a złoty account, your payment service provider sells you the currency. For a transfer ordered online in euro or another EU currency, it must show you, before you order it, the estimated currency conversion charges, the total amount in your account currency and the amount the payee will receive. The rule that a euro transfer to another EU country costs the same as a domestic one does not cover currency conversion charges. How a SEPA transfer itself works is explained separately.

It is different with a foreign transfer in a non-EU currency, for example in dollars, often made through the SWIFT system. The EU rules on showing conversion costs described above do not cover it. The Polish Payment Services Act provides for information on exchange rates, including reference rates, and how they are calculated in the framework agreement, and on the rate applied after the transfer, but in a contract with a business the parties can exclude these duties. For an invoice in a foreign currency, check the conversion cost in the fee table and in the transfer summary before you order it.

Card payments abroad

When you pay by card in a foreign currency, the conversion is done by your card issuer or, if you choose this option at the terminal, by the point accepting the payment. In the EU, for a payment in euro or another EU currency, a merchant or cash machine that offers conversion must tell you before the transaction that you can pay in the payee’s currency. In that case your own payment service provider converts it. The conversion offered at the terminal is called dynamic currency conversion (DCC). Before you confirm the payment, compare the złoty amount on the terminal with paying in the local currency, which your card issuer will convert.

Mark-up over the ECB reference rate

For card payments in euro and in currencies of EU countries outside the euro area, such as the złoty, the Czech koruna or the forint, the EU regulation on cross-border payments requires the total currency conversion charge to be shown as a percentage mark-up over the latest ECB reference rate. The payer is told the mark-up before the payment is initiated. This makes offers from different providers comparable with a single number.

An example with rounded rates: the ECB reference rate is PLN 4.4200 per euro, and a card payment of €1,000 was converted at PLN 4.5084. The mark-up is (4.5084 − 4.4200) / 4.4200 × 100 = 2.00%. Instead of PLN 4,420.00 you pay PLN 4,508.40, which is PLN 88.40 more. These rules do not apply to payments in dollars or pounds. In a contract with a business that is not a consumer, some of the information duties can be excluded, so check your provider’s fee table and framework agreement.

Conversion fee or mark-up in the rate

Some providers charge a fixed currency conversion fee, others add a percentage mark-up to the rate, and some combine both. A “no commission” claim therefore does not mean the exchange is free: the cost can sit in the rate. With a fixed fee, the amount matters, because on small payments a fixed fee weighs more.

An example: offer A has a 0.5% mark-up and no fee, offer B a 0% mark-up and a fixed fee of PLN 25. The break-even point is 25 / 0.005 = PLN 5,000. Exchanging €2,000, or PLN 8,840 at a rate of 4.4200, offer A costs PLN 44.20 and offer B PLN 25.00. For PLN 1,000, offer A costs PLN 5.00 and offer B still PLN 25.00.

How to compare currency conversion costs

To make the comparison fair, check the same scenario with every provider:

take the same amount, the same currency and the same day, because rates change during the day,
turn the provider’s rate into a mark-up over one benchmark, for example the ECB reference rate or the NBP average rate,
add fixed transfer or conversion fees and work out the total cost in złoty,
check the cost both ways, because a client’s payment is converted at the buy rate and a payment to a supplier at the sell rate,
consider keeping part of your money in the currency if both your income and your expenses are in euro.

Spread and exchange differences in tax

The rate in a provider’s table is not the same as the rate for tax purposes. For VAT, amounts on an invoice in a foreign currency are, as a rule, converted at the NBP average rate of the last working day before the tax point or, if you choose, at the latest ECB rate. For PIT and CIT, exchange differences are, as a rule, based on the rates actually applied when exchanging currency, receiving a payment or paying a liability, so the spread you pay is reflected in your tax settlement. The details are in our article on the euro business account, and the settlement is best discussed with your accounting office.

Currency exchange with Vivid

You can apply for an online business account with Vivid Business. The account is provided by Vivid Money S.A., an electronic money institution from Luxembourg, not a bank. All prices are in euro:

The Free Start plan for companies and the Standard plan for freelancers cost €0 a month and include euro accounts.
Paid plans let you open accounts in 22 currencies; for companies they start at €6.90 a month billed annually or €8.90 a month billed monthly.
On paid company plans, currency exchange between your own accounts falls within a monthly allowance starting at €10,000 depending on the plan, and above it the fee is 0.50% per exchange.
Card payments or withdrawals in a currency other than EUR cost 2% on the Free Start plan and 1% on paid company plans. As with any provider, compare the rate applied to an exchange or a card payment with the ECB reference rate for the same day.

Even on a plan with no monthly fee, individual services may come with a charge, for example extra cards, cash withdrawals above certain limits or premium features from higher plans.

Keep the white list in mind as well. It covers settlement accounts at banks and named accounts at credit unions (SKOK). If you are an active VAT payer and make transactions with Polish businesses worth more than PLN 15,000, also in euro or paid in instalments, give the account number shown in the register on your invoices. You can run a Vivid Business account alongside it, for example for payments with clients and suppliers abroad.

Vivid at a glance: euro accounts on every plan, 22 currencies on paid plans and exchange between your own accounts within a monthly allowance starting at €10,000 on paid company plans, with 0.50% per exchange above it.

A business account for euro payments

You fill in the Vivid Business application online in about 10 minutes. You get a euro account on every plan.

Open a business account

Frequently asked questions

  • What is a currency spread?

    It is the gap between a provider’s sell rate and buy rate for a currency. The provider buys currency more cheaply and sells it more dearly, and earns on the difference. The spread is built into the rate, not shown as a separate fee.

  • Subtract the buy rate from the sell rate. To express the spread as a percentage, divide the difference by the average rate and multiply by 100. If the rates sit symmetrically around the average rate, a single exchange costs roughly half the spread.

  • A high spread means that the buy and sell rates are far apart, so you lose more on every exchange. With a 2.71% spread and a €10,000 invoice, the difference from the average rate is PLN 600 in our example.

  • Not in the strict sense. A commission is a separate fee, while a spread is hidden in the rate. A provider can charge both at once, so compare the total cost of exchanging the same amount.

  • For payments in euro and in currencies of EU countries outside the euro area, the conversion cost is shown as a percentage mark-up over the latest ECB reference rate before you confirm the payment.

  • Indirectly, yes. For PIT and CIT, exchange differences are, as a rule, based on the rates actually applied when exchanging or paying, and for VAT amounts are converted at the NBP average rate or the ECB rate.

This article is for general information only and is not financial, legal or tax advice. The rates in the examples are rounded and for illustration only. Apart from Vivid’s prices, the rules described come from Regulation (EU) 2021/1230 on cross-border payments in the Union, the Polish Payment Services Act, the VAT, PIT and CIT Acts, and information from NBP and the European Central Bank. Payment services are provided by Vivid Money S.A., 21 rue Glesener, Luxembourg, L-1631, Luxembourg, an electronic money institution authorised by and under the supervision of the Commission de Surveillance du Secteur Financier in Luxembourg, under registration number W00000015.

Other articles